Eats · fun

Pie Craft πŸ•πŸ”§πŸ”¨ “Build-It-Yourself Gourmet Pizza” and of Course A Custom Milkshake 🍦🍭

If you’re ok with a ride 🚐 all the way deep into the South Shore of Long Island BUT up for an adventure 🎊 with the kids then here’s a fun outting. Pie Craft is a gourmet build it yourself pizza bar at 4585 Austin Blvd in Island Park.πŸ•πŸ”§πŸ”¨ But not only is it pizza, saladsπŸ₯— and other food but it continues on the milkshake trend that all our kids enjoy so much! 🍭🍦


From an accurate and thorough review on Trip Advisor by Bonappetitmom “When I first entered Piecraft, you see the counter immediately with many fabulous toppings. I was not familiar with Piecraft, and so I didn’t know what to expect. A staff member came over and explained the premise of the restaurant. Pie craft is not fast food nor is it a full service restaurant. After you order and pay, you a given a number to bring to your table. When your food is ready, a staff member will bring it to your table. When you are finished you can just leave the restaurant. No cleanup is required or neither is gratuities. The different types of pizza at Piecraft is enormous. You can have pizza that they feature or you can make your own.


The first step is to choose from three different types of crust. You can choose the original, whole wheat bread, spicy firecracker , sun-dried tomato and cayenne, or gluten-free, rice baked in our gluten free oven. Next is step two, a base for the pizza which include, NY Classic, Margherita Red, Pesto, The Pink Eye (vodka sauce). Then comes step three the toppings. With over 30 toppings to choose from $.99 to $2.99. You can build and create whatever you please.


I had half of their specialty pizza the Burrata Pie and half of my choosing. The toppings are fresh and placed on the pizza and then directly in their hot coal fire oven for about 5minutes. The crust is sure thin and crunchy. The pizza was delicious, crunchy and bursting with flavor. from. There is a great selections of soups and salads to choose from. I had the Burrata Plate, burrata, arugula, beets, shaved Parmigana with a balsamic drizzle. The beets were fresh roasted and the burrata was divine. I tried the Fire-Brazed Artisan Meatballs. I had the old school meatballs, red sauce with a scoop of ricotta and the buffalo chicken meatballs, spicy buffalo sauce and blue cheese dressing. The three nice sized meatballs tasted exactly how they were named.


As you head to the cashier, you are drawn to the beautiful showcase of desserts. From brownies and cake pops, to cookies, macarons and more.


At the end of the restaurant is a full liquor bar. They have signature craft cocktails, as well as beer and wine. At checkout you are given cups for the soda machine or there are other bottled beverages.


Piecraft is an ideal place for lunch, brunch or dinner. It is a very clean and modern restaurant. With many wonderful choices to choose from, there is something for everyone. It is a great place for families, teens, young adults and more. The restaurant is wonderful in that you can eat fast and then leave or stay as long as you please. This is a semi service restaurant. I would definitely come back for another meal at Piecraft.”


While of course we were there to eat dinner, we were mainly focusing on continuing our Milkshakes across New York tour. Lol 😝 Order your milkshakes right away because they take awhile to create. The kids had a lot of fun creating their own pizzas. They oohed and ahhed over the various choices.



Warning the pizzas are big and truthfully 2-3 kids can share each one but realistically building your own personal pie is part of the fun so perhaps let it go and let them enjoy the experience. ⚠️

Oh! Some great news! They have a gluten free pizza option too! Yay! πŸ‘πŸ½πŸ‘πŸ½


My husband decided to go “crazy” on his pizza and I got the wings and a chicken parm pizza!


While we were too stuffed to have the other dessert options they offered the kids enjoyed their shakes!


All in all it was a fun activity to take a bunch of kids to for dinner. Kids love a “dinner activity” and this kept them busy!

Side note- They offer birthday parties! Looked like a cute and unique place to have a party! πŸŽ‰

2 thoughts on “Pie Craft πŸ•πŸ”§πŸ”¨ “Build-It-Yourself Gourmet Pizza” and of Course A Custom Milkshake 🍦🍭

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.